Contracts to Deliver Health Care Services

Download PDF

Physicians have a fundamental ethical obligation to put the welfare of patients ahead of other considerations, including personal financial interests. This obligation requires them to consider carefully the terms and conditions of contracts to deliver health care services before entering into such contracts to ensure that those contracts do not create untenable conflicts of interests.

Ongoing evolution in the health care system continues to bring changes to medicine, including changes in reimbursement mechanisms, models for health care delivery, restrictions on referral and use of services, clinical practice guidelines, and limitations on benefits packages. While these changes are intended to enhance quality, efficiency, and safety in health care, they can also put at risk physicians’ ability to uphold professional ethical standards of informed consent and fidelity to patients and can impede physicians’ freedom to exercise independent professional judgment and tailor care to meet the needs of individual patients.

As physicians enter into various differently structured contracts to deliver health care services—with group practices, hospitals, health plans, or other entities—they should be mindful that while many arrangements have the potential to promote desired improvements in care, some arrangements also have the potential to impede patients’ interests.

When contracting to provide health care services, physicians should:

Carefully review the terms of proposed contracts or have a representative do so on their behalf to assure themselves that the arrangement:
1. minimizes conflict of interest with respect to proposed reimbursement mechanisms, financial or performance incentives, restrictions on care, or other mechanisms intended to influence physicians’ treatment recommendations or direct what care patients receive, in keeping with ethics guidance;
2. does not compromise the physician’s own financial well-being or ability to provide high-quality care through unrealistic expectations regarding utilization of services or terms that expose the physician to excessive financial risk;
3. allows the physician to appropriately exercise professional judgment;
4. includes a mechanism to address grievances and supports advocacy on behalf of individual patients;
5. permits disclosure to patients.
Negotiate modification or removal of any terms that unduly compromise physicians’ ability to uphold ethical standards.

AMA Principles of Medical Ethics: I, II, III, V, VI, VIII, IX

Read the Principles

Council Reports

PDF Contracts to Deliver Health Care Services

Related Learning

Ethics Case Speaking Out on Issues Adversely Affecting Patient Safety in a Pandemic

Ethics Case Restrictive Covenants and Patient Care in a Pandemic

Ethics in the News What Shohei Ohtani’s $700 Million Contract Says About the AMA Code

Related Opinions

See All Opinions

Opinion 1.1.1

Patient-Physician Relationships

At the heart of medicine lie relationships founded in a “covenant of trust” between patient and physician in which physicians commit themselves to responding to the needs and promoting the welfare of patients.

Opinion 1.1.6

Quality

Physicians individually and collectively share the obligation to ensure that the care patients receive is safe, effective, patient centered, timely, efficient, and equitable.

Opinion 11.2.1

Professionalism in Health Care Systems

Physicians should hold leaders accountable to meeting conditions for professionalism in health care systems. This includes advocating for changes in health care payment and delivery models to promote access to high quality care for all patients, recognizing that over-reliance on financial incentives may undermine physician professionalism.

Opinion 11.2.4

Transparency in Health Care

Physicians have an obligation to inform patients about all appropriate treatment options, the risks and benefits of alternatives, and other information that may be pertinent, including the existence of payment models, financial incentives, formularies, guidelines, or other tools that influence treatment recommendations and care.