Allocating Limited Health Care Resources

Download PDF

Physicians’ primary ethical obligation is to promote the well-being of their patients. Policies for allocating scarce health care resources can impede their ability to fulfill that obligation, whether those policies address situations of chronically limited resources, such as ICU (intensive care unit) beds, medications, or solid organs for transplantation, or “triage” situations in times of scarcity, such as access to ventilators during an influenza pandemic.

As professionals dedicated to protecting the interests of their patients, physicians thus have a responsibility to contribute their expertise to developing allocation policies that are fair and safeguard the welfare of patients.

Individually and collectively through the profession, physicians should advocate for policies and procedures that allocate scarce health care resources fairly among patients, in keeping with the following criteria:

Base allocation policies on criteria relating to medical need, including urgency of need, likelihood and anticipated duration of benefit, and change in quality of life. In limited circumstances, it may be appropriate to take into consideration the amount of resources required for successful treatment. It is not appropriate to base allocation policies on social worth, perceived obstacles to treatment, patient contribution to illness, past use of resources, or other non-medical characteristics.
Give first priority to those patients for whom treatment will avoid premature death or extremely poor outcomes, then to patients who will experience the greatest change in quality of life, when there are very substantial differences among patients who need access to the scarce resource(s).
Use an objective, flexible, transparent mechanism to determine which patients will receive the resource(s) when there are not substantial differences among patients who need access to the scarce resource(s).
Explain the applicable allocation policies or procedures to patients who are denied access to the scarce resource(s) and to the public.

AMA Principles of Medical Ethics: I, VII

Read the Principles

Council Reports

PDF Allocating Limited Health Care Resources

Related Learning

Ethics Case Prioritizing the Rest of Health Care in a Public Health Crisis

Ethics Case Protecting Public Health & Vulnerable Populations in a Pandemic

Ethics Case Fair Access to Limited Critical Care Resources

Ethics Case Crisis Standards of Care

Ethics at the Movies The God Committee and Allocation of Finite Resources

Related Opinions

See All Opinions

Opinion 1.1.6

Quality

Physicians individually and collectively share the obligation to ensure that the care patients receive is safe, effective, patient centered, timely, efficient, and equitable.

Opinion 6.2.1

Guidelines for Organ Transplantation from Deceased Donors

Organ transplantation is unique in that it involves two patients, donor and recipient, both of whose interests must be protected. Concern for the patient should always take precedence over advancing scientific knowledge.

Opinion 11.1.1

Defining Basic Health Care

Because health care is a fundamental human good, society has an obligation to make access to an adequate level of care available to all its members, regardless of ability to pay.

Opinion 11.1.2

Physician Stewardship of Health Care Resources

Physicians have an obligation to be prudent and responsible stewards of health care resources.

Opinion 11.2.1

Professionalism in Health Care Systems

Physicians should hold leaders accountable to meeting conditions for professionalism in health care systems. This includes advocating for changes in health care payment and delivery models to promote access to high quality care for all patients, recognizing that over-reliance on financial incentives may undermine physician professionalism.

Opinion 11.2.4

Transparency in Health Care

Physicians have an obligation to inform patients about all appropriate treatment options, the risks and benefits of alternatives, and other information that may be pertinent, including the existence of payment models, financial incentives, formularies, guidelines, or other tools that influence treatment recommendations and care.